Last updated on January 14th, 2021 at 12:07 am
In this review, we’ll compare custom night guards from Cheeky vs ClearClub vs Remi to help you decide if any are right for you.
Tired of waking up with jaw pain, a stiff jaw, or worn down teeth? These are all indications that you may be a chronic grinder! Your dentist may have diagnosed you with bruxism, which is the official term for this condition. What can you do about it? Well, some opt for botox, apparently. But the more popular option is simply to wear a mouthguard while you sleep. Night guards are a proven way to protect your chompers, jaw, and face from the impact of grinding during the night.
Typically patients buy custom night guards through their dentist, but direct-to-consumer (D2C) companies have made it easier than ever to get custom mouth guards online without an in-person visit. Companies like Remi, ClearClub, and Cheeky are the leaders, making it much more affordable, as well convenient.
Today, we’ll compare them head to head — Cheeky vs ClearClub vs Remi — so you can decide which (if any) is right for you. In our opinion, these are the top custom night guard brands on the market, so let’s review.
How does buying D2C night guards work?
Traditionally, custom teeth guards for sleeping were purchased from your dentist. You’d have to go in to have your dentist to take measurements and make an impression of your teeth. Then, he or she would send your impressions and data to a company that would custom make a mouth guard just for you. Sometimes you’d even have to go back to the dentist and have the guard tested to make sure it fits. Several trips to the dentist and a pretty expensive middleman later, you’d have your custom mouth guard. God forbid you’d lose or break you mouth guard and have to restart the process from scratch.
Thankfully the internet has changed all that. Direct to consumer companies are eliminating all the back and forth with the dentist, as well as dramatically decreasing the cost. So, assuming you have an otherwise healthy mouth and your dentist recommends a mouthguard for grinding, you now have options when it comes to sourcing a custom mouth guard.
In terms of how to buy a night guard online, all of the different online brands we are reviewing here (Cheeky, ClearClub and Remi) all make it very easy. Each will send you a kit in the mail which you’ll use to take an impression of your teeth at home, by yourself.
The impression kit involves putty in a tray that you press your teeth into to create a mold. Basically, you are biting into the kit provided by Cheeky or ClearClub or Remi, and then sending that back to them. They make your custom-fitted night guards and delivery them to your door when ready. You can simply buy a single guard, OR join a replacement plan to receive a new one every few months. Totally up to you.
How much do custom night guards cost from Remi, ClearClub, or Cheeky?
Traditionally, if you go to the dentist and purchase a custom night guard, you’ll end up spending $300 to $500 – if not more. After all, multiple in-person visits to the dentist aren’t cheap! Cheeky, Remi and ClearClub all offer custom teeth guards for $300. If you only want to guard one have of your teeth — i.e. just an upper (or lower) guard — the price drops to $200. Plus, these companies are almost always running promotions, so you’re like to find a coupon code.
What’s the difference between Cheeky, ClearClub and Remi?
Here are more specifics on each brand of mouthguard.
Review of Cheeky’s mouth guards
Cheeky has soft guards made out of a thermoplastic and hybrid ones with a hard acrylic exterior with a soft thermoplastic interior. Thus for those preferring a more cushioned material to rest their teeth against at night, Cheeky is probably your best option. You can choose from upper, lower, or upper and lower options in 1.5, 2 or 3mm thicknesses — so lots to customize as well. And if it doesn’t work for you, they offer a generous return policy — full refund at any point! — so +1 for strong customer service.
They allow you to buy a mouth guard one-time, or with their replacement plan, Cheeky will send you a new night guard every three months so that you always have a fresh set without any wear and tear.
Review of ClearClub’s custom mouth guards
ClearClub guards are made of BPA-free, latex-free and non-allergenic materials with a hard acrylic on the outside and a soft layer on the inside. They come in upper, lower, or upper and lower options in 1.3, 2 and 3mm thicknesses. The company notes the upper 1.3mm size is the most popular.
You have the option of a one-time purchase or of a renewal plan to receive a new guard at a discount every three, four or six months.
One thing that makes ClearClub stand out is its fun design choices. If that’s something you would like or you’re purchasing it for a child/teen, the brand offers a range of colors, multi-color options and “dynamic duo” designs to choose from. This may make it easier to convince your kid to use it!
Review of Remi’s night guards for teeth grinders
Remi only offers the upper night guards in the basic clear style, all in the same thickness with a hard exterior and soft interior. They’re made of BPA-free plastic that’s dental-grade.
We like Remi’s 30-day money-back guarantee, and the cost (as you’ll see in the comparison chart below) is lower than Cheeky and ClearClub. So, we’d recommend that you start with Remi at the moment.
Cheeky vs ClearClub vs Remi: Which custom night guard is best for you?
To help you compare these three brands side by side, we put together the following chart:
Custom Night Guard Reviews: Cheeky vs ClearClub vs Remi
One-time purchase: $159 for impression kit and one (upper or lower);
$218 for impression kit and both upper and lower
Replacement plan: $229 annually, or $49 for impression kit and $59 every three months
One-time purchase: $125 for impression kit and one (upper or lower);
$195 for impression kit and both upper and lower
Replacement plan: $95 per guard or $148 for both plus $35 every three months, $40 every four months or $45 every six months
Remi Single: $149 for impression kit and top guard
Remi Club: $99 for impression kit and top guard plus $49 every 6 months for replacements
|Shipping||Free||Shipping and taxes vary||Free on Remi Club or $9 on Remi Single orders|
|FSA/HSA eligible?||No, but can provide an itemized receipt for you to claim yourself||Yes||Yes|
|Returns||Full money back guarantee at any time||60-day money back guarantee||30-day money back guarantee|
|Mouth Guard Customization||
-Upper, lower, or upper and lower guards
-1.5, 2, or 3mm thicknesses
-Soft or hybrid
-Upper, lower, or upper and lower
-1.3, 2, or 3 mm thicknesses
-Color and design choices
-Offers custom whitening kits
The chart helps you see the similarities and differences between these direct-to-consumer night guard options. Here are similar positives of all three:
- Remi, Cheeky and ClearClub all make it easy to take impressions of your teeth from home and have custom night guards sent to your door.
- All of them give you guards that fit the mold of your teeth, which is a major step up in comfort level from one-size-fits-all or boil-and-bite guards you purchase from a pharmacy.
- They all give you customization without the hassle or prices of the dentist.
- All three brands allow you to make a one-time purchase. That includes the impression. But, the subscriptions are a nice way to get lower-cost ones sent fresh to your home on a regular basis.
- They all have money-back offers if you’re not satisfied, so you don’t have much to lose for trying out the service.
What are the differences? The chart shows that the pricing differs for the one-time purchase, and they all have slightly different replacement plans. Shipping prices vary as well. Cheeky offers free shipping, yet their price is slightly higher than Remi or ClearClub, so you can choose to see this as backing in shipping costs. The replacement plans are a nice feature because you don’t have to re-purchase or do the impression kit over again after your initial go around. Plus you get a discount on each new guard by signing up for the recurring subscription.
The Verdict: Which custom night guard is best — Cheeky, ClearClub, or Remi?
Aside from price, the main differentiator is the personalization options beyond the custom fit. Remi keeps things simple with the one clear style in the same thickness for everyone. This could be fine if you’re not looking for any extra bells and whistles, and the brand also offers custom whitening kits you could order along with your night guards. Remi only offers the top guard, so if you want the bottom or both you’d need to go with one of the other brands.
Cheeky and ClearClub give more choices. With both brands, you can pick upper, lower, or upper and lower guards, and you get to decide on the thickness. At that point, the two brands differ in customization, so think about if one’s offerings are a priority for you over the other. Cheeky gives the choice of a soft guard or a hybrid guard that has a hard exterior and soft interior. ClearClub, on the other hand, makes their night guards more fun with choices in color and designs. This might be a good choice if you’re drawn to decorative accessories or if you’re buying this for a child or teen that might be resistant to wearing it.
It’s easy to try out any of these brands since you can get your money back if you’re not satisfied. Plus, Cheeky offers a promo code that could help you save, yet the others are more affordable from the start. Since you have the choice of a one-time purchase, you may want to try out each service before signing up for a replacement plan. You can see how the guards fit and take advantage of Cheeky’s money-back guarantee if needed. As for which one is best for you, we hope this overview and chart can help you choose based on which factors are priorities to you.
Our personal favorite? At the moment, because it’s the lowest price plan and so simple to sign up, we recommend Remi. Click here to get started with them now. As we mentioned before, if you prefer a softer material to guard your teeth at night, go with Cheeky for just a few dollars more.