Disclosure: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Jessica Turner

Third & Main – Is it the Best Home Decor Box You Can Buy?

  1. Home
  2. Home Goods
  3. Third and Main Reviews
Rating: 4.4 / 5
4.4/5

The subscription box (AKA the admittedly jauntier “sub box”) is having a moment, and honestly, we get it. Who doesn’t love getting surprises in the mail? And with options for beauty products, clothing, self-care, plants, fitness, wine, art, and so much more, there really is something for everyone. But arguably leading the pack is the home decor sub box. Like other options in this category, these seasonal or monthly boxes are filled to the brim with home decor pieces that are shipped directly to your door at scheduled times throughout the year.

 

Sounds great, right? But with no shortage of options, where should you even begin? As it happens, one company is making the decision-making process pretty easy. Since 2017, Third & Main has curated high-quality home decor with its award-winning Modern Farmhouse, Contemporary, and recently released Luxe boxes.

 

If you’re considering a home decor sub box, read on for everything you need to know about Third & Main – and why we think it’s the best home decor box you can buy.

 

What is a home decor subscription box?

It’s pretty much what it sounds like – a curated selection of home decor pieces. Like subscription boxes in general, the home decor box comes in a wide range of design aesthetics and options. Is your design style modern farmhouse all the way, or are you into more contemporary designs? Do you want a few smaller goodies delivered monthly, or a bigger box sent quarterly for that seasonal decor transition? What’s your price point?

 

Source: Third & Main

 

Musing through questions like these can help you zero in on a box that you’ll look forward to throughout the year. Keep in mind that there are variations in price, quality, and customer service, depending on the company you choose.

 

Who should consider a seasonal home decor sub box?

A seasonal home decor sub box works for just about anyone, whether you have a natural eye for design or you need all the help you can get. Wondering if it’s right for you?

 

  • Convenience: You like the idea of having home decor pieces curated and shipped right to your door.
  • Trendy: You like freshening up your home’s decor to reflect the changing seasons.
  • Time-saving: You don’t have time to run around to individual boutiques in search of home decor.
  • Designer: You have the time to shop, but you have trouble choosing pieces that work together well and you know you’d benefit from a designer’s touch.
  • Fun: You enjoy the element of surprise, but you also like having choices.

 

If any of the above applies, you’d probably enjoy a home decor sub box – which brings us to Third & Main.

 

Third and Main review

The company launched in 2017 when the home decor subscription box category was still in its infancy, and today it offers three separate seasonal boxes in addition to holiday decor bundles and ready-to-ship gift boxes. From the beginning, Third & Main has prioritized supporting local makers and businesses, which means you can expect home decor pieces you won’t find at big-box retailers.

 

Typical items include textiles like throws, runners, and hand-sewn pillow covers, specialty kitchen items like serving ware, scented goods like candles, soaps, and lotions, faux greens, and florals, along with vessels for displaying them – you get the idea.

 

The Modern Farmhouse subscription box

Third & Main’s flagship offering is the Modern Farmhouse box, which remains a bestseller today. Even if you don’t know it by name, you very likely recognize this design aesthetic – Joanna Gaines and Magnolia popularized the modern twist on the classic farmhouse style, which is characterized by neutral colors, clean lines, natural elements, and simple comfort.

 

The Third & Main Modern Farmhouse box includes five to six handpicked, designer-curated items, and members get a first pick of two to three options to personalize their boxes. Options for a past box included a beaded cake stand, a chunky hand-knit pumpkin, a maple wood wreath, a plumberry magnolia wreath, and a cozy throw in a choice of colors. Each box comes with a small guide containing tips for styling your new home decor pieces, which is a nice touch.

 

Third & Main’s Spring 2022 Modern Farmhouse Box options

 

The Contemporary box

Third & Main rolled out its Contemporary box in 2019 in recognition of those members looking for home decor pieces that are a little cleaner, more minimal, and modern. The contemporary style of decorating is hyper-focused on simplicity, with lots of clean lines, texture, and subtle sophistication, which creates an overall effect that’s both sleek and fresh and entirely separate from the modern farmhouse aesthetic.

 

When it comes to contemporary decor, the key is being mindful and intentional. Past Third & Main Contemporary boxes have included pieces with beautiful glass textures, metallic accents, and organic elements. Like the Modern Farmhouse box, members can expect five to six pieces per box and options for personalizing. Remember, the idea is that these decor items build on one another over time, creating an authentic, stylish vibe for your home.

 

Third & Main’s Fall 2022 Contemporary Box options

 

The Luxe box

In 2022, Third & Main launched the Luxe box, and it’s aptly named. The focus is on prestige items and brands for an over-the-top, luxurious experience that begins when the oversized box arrives. The Luxe box sold out on its debut, which tells you a lot – clearly, the world was ready for a decor box at a significantly higher price point!

 

Subscribers to the Luxe box are in for a treat. Think interior designer in a box – it’s filled with high-end pieces that stand alone or work beautifully together. This is an ultra-luxurious, upscale version of the Contemporary box with stylish finds that you’d find in your favorite boutique. The fall 2022 Luxe box, for example, includes options like velvet pillows, preto agate photo frames, and stunning glass hurricanes.

 

Luxe box members are also automatically enrolled into a prestigious VIP program with a few extra perks.

 

Third & Main’s Fall 2022 Luxe Box option 2

 

How does a Third & Main membership work?

Customer service is a priority for Third & Main, so the membership process is designed for simplicity. Once you’ve decided which box best suits your aesthetic and budget, you just add it to the cart and follow the steps to check out. You’ll receive your product selection survey within 24 hours of purchase. Keep in mind that options go quickly, so depending on when you subscribe, you may have limited options for your first box.

 

Subscriptions are recurring, and you’ll be automatically charged for each seasonal box unless you cancel. To do so, you just need to log in and cancel before the 15th of each month. Cancellations made after the 15th will be applied to the next seasonal box.

 

Members have the option of pausing or skipping one box per calendar year – you just need to contact Third & Main directly. Returns on items in your box aren’t accepted, but if anything arrives damaged, the company is happy to offer replacements.

 

What does a Third & Main membership cost?

Modern Farmhouse subscription box$129 + $10 shipping
Contemporary subscription box$149 + $10 shipping
Luxe subscription box$499 + $24.99 shipping

Current subscribers are grandfathered into free shipping, but new members will spend $10 on shipping for the Modern Farmhouse and Contemporary boxes. Shipping for the Luxe box is $24.99. According to the company, this is a reflection of rising costs affecting industries across the country.

 

Best home decor subscription box: Third & Main vs Decocrated vs Home Decor

Third & Main vs Decocrated vs Home Decor

   
What do you get?(depending on box selection)

Seasonal boxes (4x/year) of seasonal decor + optional add-on holiday
boxes
Seasonal box with up to 8 curated pieces + styling guide with pro
tips.
4-5 handcrafted items every month after you sign up for the
subscription service with different themes every month.
Cost

Farmhouse: $129/box

Contemporary: $149/box

Luxe: $499/box

Quarterly: $89.99/box

Annual: $75/box

3-month plan: $40/mo

6-month subscription: $37/mo

Annual plan: $35/mo

Free shipping?🟡 unless you purchase annual subscription🟡 on orders over $99
Can purchase items a la carte?
Seasonal boxes?
Customizable?
Can all view items before delivery?
Website

 

What makes Third & Main different?

Beyond its choice of three distinct boxes, there are a few things that make Third & Main stand out in the relatively crowded home decor subscription box market.

 

  • It’s not a discount decor box. You may have already figured that out by the price point. But when it comes to quality home decor pieces, you really do get what you pay for. And in the case of Third & Main, that means a boutique shopping service that is shipped right to your door. The Third & Main team spends hours and hours searching and sampling products to include in all three sub boxes, all in an effort to create a beautiful, cohesive unboxing experience with pieces you’ll be excited to have in your home.
  • There’s a cumulative effect. Third & Main boxes are designed to build upon one another and on your existing interior design so that your home decor aesthetic evolves organically. Since the boxes ship quarterly, you’ll have fresh decor on hand to transition between seasons.
  • Members are true VIPs. Members of Third & Main enjoy special perks like discounts, early access to product selections, new product launches, seasonal bundles, and members-only secret sales held throughout the year.

 

Our experience with Third & Main

We received items from Third & Main’s Fall 2022 Contemporary Box and we loved them! We’re so excited to continue to expand with their other boxes in the future – it matched really well with our existing home decor but inspired me to start modifying our decor for the season, too! Living in California sometimes makes me forget about the season change, so I was really excited about the cozy updates.

 

The items were delivered in a timely manner & customer service was great in letting us see some of the items beforehand. I totally understand now why the boxes sell out as fast as they do! Pictured below are some of the items in our kitchen!

 

Third & Main vases from the contemporary box fall 2022 displayed in our home

 

What do people say about Third & Main?

The consensus online is overwhelmingly positive from bloggers, influencers, YouTubers, and members alike. You’ll find Third & Main featured in the 18 Best Home Decor Subscription Boxes – 2022 Readers’ Choice Awards, My Subscription Addiction, Decorhint, The Pink Envelope, and more.

 

Members have a lot of good things to say too:

 

Summer 2022 Modern Farmhouse box: “This box allows me to decorate my home with stylish, quality items that I wouldn’t have necessarily picked out on my own. It makes interior design a breeze. Love all the items I received in my summer box, especially the square antique brass holders and can’t wait for what the fall box has in store!

 

Finally ordered Third and Main and it’s such a quality product. Loved being able to see what I was ordering ahead of time and getting some choice in the process. Quality items and they are good all year long. If you like what you see, suggest you order.

 

Spring 2022 Contemporary box: “I’ve been eyeing the Third & Main subscription box since Fall 2021, and every season the box I liked best was sold out before I could get to it. Finally, this Spring 2022, my choice was available so I went for it! And I’m so pleased I did. Everything in the spring box met or exceeded my expectations. The quality is excellent. Looking forward to Summer 2022!

 

Summer 2022 Luxe box: “I finally gave in and ordered my very First Luxe Box (the Summer Luxe) and boy, was I in for a treat! This is such a well-curated box for entertaining. I love every item in the box and the quality on each item is exceptional…not to say the other Third & Main Boxes are any different but with this one, they have simply outdone themselves! Unpacking everything was a whole “Luxe” experience too and I am still reeling from the “high” so to speak…;-) Their Customer Service is awesome too. I did not want the original Server set that came in this box as they were made of bone and they willingly substituted it with gold ones….which are gorgeous! All said and done, this is well worth the steep price & I look forward eagerly to my second box! Thanks, Third & Main Team!

 

The verdict: Is Third & Main’s home decor subscription box worth it?

There are lots of choices in the home decor subscription box category, but if you’re looking for a well-curated box to suit your modern farmhouse, contemporary, or high-end sense of style, you’ll do well to look to Third & Main.

 

Have you tried Third & Main’s home decor subscription box or any other home decor subs? We’d love to hear about your experience in the comments below!

Discover more innovative home startups

Share this post

Discover the latest
D2C wellness products

And get exclusive discounts!